Whedonesque Mobile : Comments on 11472 : SBC reviews Astonishing X-Men Hardcover.

September 28 2006

SBC reviews Astonishing X-Men Hardcover. Quite positive and also provides information on the extras.

In Astonishing X-Men, Joss Whedon and John Cassaday have accomplished that rare thing: to produce an accessible, well-structured, well-written new take on long-established characters which is as accessible to new readers as it is respectful to longtime fans, and looks beautiful to boot.

This being a Marvel Hardcover, we also get a slew of extras, and this book�s selection is better than most. In addition to the expected character sketches and cover variants, there�s an in-depth interview with Cassaday and some tongue-in-cheek e-mails which shed some light on Whedon�s writing approach to the book. Coupled with a genuine-feeling foreword from Brian K. Vaughan, it�s a great package, and one which demands to be read by X-Men fans, Whedonites and lovers of great superhero comics alike.

Numfar PTB | 14:09 CET | 6 comments total | tags: x-men, marvel, hardcover, joss whedon, john cassaday, brian k vaughan

Dammit, am I going to have to get the hardcover as well as having all the comics and the softcover trades? I just might, for the extras...

Kiddo | September 28, 16:55 CET

I'm confused...hasn't the hardcover been out a while?

pat32082 | September 28, 16:56 CET

Yes indeed.

Simon | September 28, 17:02 CET

According to Amazon it was published April 26, 2006. That's the first detailed review I've read, though (not to say there aren't others, but I don't tend to look for them - I just stumble across them on here).

Kiddo | September 28, 17:02 CET

I finally ordered this a week ago, and it will be my first time to read it, I haven't read anything of the X-men, ever. I'm realy looking forward to the arrival.

the Groosalugg | September 28, 22:24 CET

wow, Groosalugg -- you're in for one heck of a ride. there's tons of x-men backstory, and joss takes off at near light speed.

ummm. enjoy!

stuart | September 29, 05:22 CET

You need to log in to be able to post comments.
About membership.

« Older Serenity Tales: Big Damn Comic Boo... | Jewel Staite returning to Stargate... Newer »